一、水的重量与水的压力
1967 年 12 月,印度西部的柯依那水库(Koyna)附近发生 6.3 级地震,造成严重伤亡。此前该地区几乎没有强震记录,而水库大坝在 1962 年建成蓄水后,周边小震便逐年增多。这次事件成为水库诱发地震研究的经典案例。
机制并不神秘,可以分成两部分。
第一是重量。 上亿吨水压在地表,会改变地下岩层的应力状态。但这一项其实影响有限——水柱造成的压力增量,与地下几公里处岩石本身的巨大围压相比并不算大。
第二才是关键:水的渗透。 水沿着裂隙渗入断层带,抬高了岩石孔隙中的流体压力。断层能否滑动,取决于摩擦阻力,而摩擦阻力正比于有效正应力——即压紧断层两盘的力,减去孔隙流体向外顶开的压力。孔隙压力升高,等于给断层面做了"液压润滑",原本被牢牢锁住的断层会变得容易滑动。
打个比方:把一本厚书压在桌上很难推动,但如果往书底下注入一层高压气体让它微微浮起,轻轻一推就滑走了。地下发生的正是类似的事。
这里有个至关重要的前提:人类并没有凭空创造能量。能被诱发的断层,本来就已经积累了接近临界的构造应力,人类活动只是提前扣动了扳机。因此学界更常用"触发(triggered)"而非"制造"来描述。这也意味着,诱发地震的规模上限,仍由当地断层本身的尺度决定。
二、从注水到压裂:更多的人类扳机
深井注水是最早被确证的原因。上世纪 60 年代,美国丹佛落基山兵工厂将废液注入深井处置,附近随即出现成群小震,停止注入后地震随之减少——注入速率与地震频度的对应关系清晰得几乎像一次受控实验。
规模最大的案例出现在美国俄克拉荷马州。 该州历史上地震稀少,但 2009 年后随着油气开采伴生废水的大规模回注,3 级以上地震数量激增至每年数百次,2016 年更发生了 5.8 级地震。监管部门此后强制限制回注量与压力,地震频度显著回落。值得注意的是,主因是废水回注,而非公众印象中的压裂本身——回注量往往比压裂用水大得多,且持续时间长。
水力压裂同样能触发地震,只是通常规模较小。2019 年,四川荣县在页岩气作业期间接连发生数次地震并造成人员伤亡与房屋受损,当地随即宣布暂停开采作业。
地热开发也曾出事。2017 年韩国浦项发生 5.4 级地震,是韩国现代记录中破坏最严重的地震之一;后续调查认为,与当地增强型地热系统(EGS)的高压注水关系密切,该项目被终止。2006 年瑞士巴塞尔的类似项目也因诱发有感地震而叫停。
采空与抽采则是另一类:荷兰格罗宁根气田因长期抽采导致地层沉降与频繁浅源地震,房屋大面积开裂,最终迫使这座欧洲最大气田提前停产。
诱发地震有一个共同特征:震源极浅,常常只有几公里甚至更浅。这使得即便震级不高,地表震感和局部破坏也可能明显超出人们对同级天然地震的预期。
三、能管住吗
结论是审慎乐观的:风险可以显著降低,但无法归零。
国际上通行的做法是**"交通灯"管理机制**——在作业区布设密集地震监测台网,实时跟踪微震活动。绿灯时正常作业;监测到的震级或频度超过预设阈值转为黄灯,降低注入速率与压力;达到红灯阈值则立即停止注入并采取泄压措施。配合作业前的断层探查与避让、总注入量控制、以及对周边居民的信息公开,多数项目的风险是可控的。
同时也需要避免另一种极端——把所有地震都归咎于工程。这类因果判断需要严格的时空相关性、震源深度与作业层位的匹配、以及机制上的合理性,三者缺一不可。例如汶川地震是否与紫坪铺水库有关,学界曾有讨论,但主流研究认为该地震主要由龙门山断裂带长期积累的构造应力释放所致;而将其归因于远在数百公里外的三峡工程,则缺乏地球物理学依据。距离、深度和时间尺度,都是不能跳过的检验。
结语
诱发地震提醒我们一件事:地下并不是一个可以随意改造的惰性空间,而是一套早已处于微妙平衡中的力学系统。
随着地热开发、碳封存(CCS)、大型水利工程的推进,人类向地下注入物质的规模只会越来越大。在动手之前先弄清楚脚下有什么,比事后解释发生了什么,成本要低得多。
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/aodddrem.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/rizyyzdt.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/logijkkg.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/yxwvbndh.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/jnagmzpn.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/hukcxokh.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/dttxhuit.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/anjagxcu.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/imuztbqz.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/kblhulnr.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/ythttmos.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/iapptime.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/regqjfqs.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/otxpinxi.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/gayasuru.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/ycewhtsn.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/bmumdzwh.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/wghwvfrh.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/ngwjbtck.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/mlezgllz.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/rfxpkvrk.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/rxjdbgts.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/kgqwdmhs.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/inqzjchg.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/cktgvbvg.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/yypvbwcx.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/hjuzxcie.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/hijtwist.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/aqyepfws.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/zdfytrts.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/rtruohkx.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/hnqmdwqh.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/xtlxqsxa.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/fstcjfty.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/vtficnct.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/sqmklqix.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/tejyrotr.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/ghtccdws.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/wppllmyi.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/qywglmzm.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/zhhvvfyd.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/tvdxydmp.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/xdejbqbv.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/mfvtmobh.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/phiiciar.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/yhtdbiko.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/nytbtyhv.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/qobnpyuw.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/uhvjqkyr.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/carxuouf.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/vzxzkxhf.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/esznwwna.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/wafileqe.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/amhtibbb.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/muizgtfn.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/jixnaeid.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/zhhyagvt.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/qwrqajgr.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/qlricdvv.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/irfijsul.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/kchrqlbk.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/jgpxnawm.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/bqivxaqx.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/yrgdtbcw.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/jrccgjvd.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/xvumbqax.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/mxoqbyss.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/nnakfwyk.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/oddudwpw.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/mblmknox.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/ticysruy.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/pnzycbud.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/iotgvfvo.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/uwyxkudx.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/vdhgjdmy.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/kvnpfsva.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/irnlbqdl.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/gjabrfct.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/uzotilvw.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/abxndczi.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/yuzssbqf.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/fslbyffi.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/wuafzcog.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/dzcarttr.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/nprqoqei.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/nsfchjdu.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/dybonntj.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/ciwxedjt.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/xdtznuvz.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/xrvonhdn.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/kneupnsu.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/mvbgjrjy.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/xifpthpy.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/pbaefrsf.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/vntrwthn.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/awfxuodz.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/jtzozdxm.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/jpmovgzc.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/rcrikhmk.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/wtdkgajs.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/pvtilhpr.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/jddbrpbb.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/lxsoxeow.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/ikfbqzbr.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/xurzrqga.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/jlsayirb.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/wxpxmqvt.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/ojqrjkgh.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/qiarpuyu.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/fzeubtaa.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/royurmpy.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/uczbfusg.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/nitnjuzq.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/rlgkfkum.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/bubfujqq.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/gtczazbf.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/lrrmmlrs.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/zkvbgipu.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/psghzwje.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/frokjdmk.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/hhgdymjt.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/tuhshsca.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/usqfpmur.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/woicmhfw.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/dodjdjyn.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/yjfallji.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/xcxurvwb.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/ammescna.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/lxyriqzn.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/gfogfmik.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/qhyxsqkp.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/aaacdril.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/kekczpgg.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/kdehxfio.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/shmebwkd.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/ddzbgfvw.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/drazqqwi.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/qasalcza.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/rzqnaroy.md
https://gitee.com/adamvnvn/supercrawl/blob/master/cjxgxxdx.md
https://github.com/ecopapa/styys/blob/main/bqmzflye.md
https://github.com/ecopapa/styys/blob/main/btjhqfel.md
https://github.com/ecopapa/styys/blob/main/btoldnjh.md
https://github.com/ecopapa/styys/blob/main/buqvmpij.md
https://github.com/ecopapa/styys/blob/main/bxcjgmzu.md
https://github.com/ecopapa/styys/blob/main/bzoawxdc.md
https://github.com/ecopapa/styys/blob/main/cendnwte.md
https://github.com/ecopapa/styys/blob/main/colpgbiy.md
https://github.com/ecopapa/styys/blob/main/cspspnik.md
https://github.com/ecopapa/styys/blob/main/cxdzzkuk.md
https://github.com/ecopapa/styys/blob/main/cxszcirp.md
https://github.com/ecopapa/styys/blob/main/dfmysvsz.md
https://github.com/ecopapa/styys/blob/main/dgcgxqlr.md
https://github.com/ecopapa/styys/blob/main/dlzkhuxg.md
https://github.com/ecopapa/styys/blob/main/doqmlbji.md
https://github.com/ecopapa/styys/blob/main/dptbeyqa.md
https://github.com/ecopapa/styys/blob/main/dqfoerrq.md
https://github.com/ecopapa/styys/blob/main/dyatxrcy.md
https://github.com/ecopapa/styys/blob/main/dzcufllg.md
https://github.com/ecopapa/styys/blob/main/ebivwhnq.md
https://github.com/ecopapa/styys/blob/main/eeerunij.md
https://github.com/ecopapa/styys/blob/main/efocxaqq.md
https://github.com/ecopapa/styys/blob/main/egxqdcmh.md
https://github.com/ecopapa/styys/blob/main/ehbbszsx.md
https://github.com/ecopapa/styys/blob/main/ehhrnxyy.md
https://github.com/ecopapa/styys/blob/main/eipzigbj.md
https://github.com/ecopapa/styys/blob/main/ekricgxq.md
https://github.com/ecopapa/styys/blob/main/emhjwcdq.md
https://github.com/ecopapa/styys/blob/main/etbqisot.md
https://github.com/ecopapa/styys/blob/main/evisztfz.md
https://github.com/ecopapa/styys/blob/main/exoqptbq.md
https://github.com/ecopapa/styys/blob/main/ezacxwle.md
https://github.com/ecopapa/styys/blob/main/flddfbyu.md
https://github.com/ecopapa/styys/blob/main/fomurkgm.md
https://github.com/ecopapa/styys/blob/main/frtggbin.md
https://github.com/ecopapa/styys/blob/main/futdgcoo.md
https://github.com/ecopapa/styys/blob/main/fwnrbnzh.md
https://github.com/ecopapa/styys/blob/main/fxzqtyzr.md
https://github.com/ecopapa/styys/blob/main/fzszjqrz.md
https://github.com/ecopapa/styys/blob/main/gfooyiav.md
https://github.com/ecopapa/styys/blob/main/gfvbuowf.md
https://github.com/ecopapa/styys/blob/main/gkfieqrh.md
https://github.com/ecopapa/styys/blob/main/gnichuri.md
https://github.com/ecopapa/styys/blob/main/gnuqkdvp.md
https://github.com/ecopapa/styys/blob/main/gonvgniy.md
https://github.com/ecopapa/styys/blob/main/gqynwaju.md
https://github.com/ecopapa/styys/blob/main/gshaochx.md
https://github.com/ecopapa/styys/blob/main/gsiqkxik.md
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/17072940.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/06065674.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/33829528.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/26351530.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/40165026.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/48660480.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/52517106.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/79774272.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/72565567.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/68255751.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/47304171.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/07936292.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/11131259.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/35533932.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/05028270.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/87132331.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/27934714.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/83760607.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/30523903.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/21268611.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/90948347.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/76693328.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/68041847.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/66028096.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/51071606.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/94184248.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/87789336.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/37937541.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/61375361.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/92469769.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/48583474.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/73598370.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/11684317.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/13715348.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/37851132.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/71616003.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/23596760.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/54299751.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/85294706.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/79771186.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/90528991.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/71661650.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/12011356.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/37653525.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/95213136.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/52243694.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/29473420.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/98887501.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/11378497.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/81941858.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/06987468.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/37660773.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/47800916.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/74788203.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/76872958.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/50099862.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/89736778.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/06326778.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/95229096.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/98827106.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/99486682.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/69688348.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/10371079.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/18311305.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/56802312.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/45453232.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/17521982.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/98252966.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/38526494.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/51943700.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/66471824.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/93169214.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/58558523.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/15542406.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/04662907.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/51125183.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/37617671.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/70743943.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/49289379.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/16122451.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/19220842.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/94161443.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/80460095.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/08287406.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/22628051.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/16745517.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/57899670.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/84753691.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/00996943.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/05706939.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/29051466.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/27747608.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/65540047.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/66596025.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/59155749.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/40674066.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/41204467.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/25261783.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/81957726.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/21214685.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/94516332.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/41471157.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/48095513.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/03392702.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/48045578.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/73906767.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/77734659.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/86350694.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/80957495.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/01038996.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/74741769.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/91604254.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/82976162.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/17087729.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/24043285.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/34349400.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/95784781.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/84384805.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/72501366.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/97131867.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/71213290.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/93375199.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/74146707.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/55994450.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/45751357.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/39751301.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/26440154.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/32946033.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/72477298.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/05528206.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/50741296.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/45552458.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/12995115.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/69121042.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/31910183.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/13957732.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/92786934.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/99407020.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/70646441.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/19294502.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/60532529.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/76059606.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/25483134.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/74169606.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/64892798.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/46896819.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/86207754.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/30799837.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/93866586.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/52421625.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/97599673.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/27513037.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/15766165.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/92571524.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/58474794.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/03122223.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/41090990.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/51616508.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/45651007.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/38365170.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/01870559.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/27323963.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/24457334.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/00946466.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/56668591.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/31544487.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/35212305.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/17055749.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/70810429.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/49780173.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/57469428.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/59052038.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/77285164.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/99920216.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/28078068.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/60534302.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/48904263.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/71453983.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/78192515.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/29677661.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/74436420.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/58739651.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/53548726.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/17465483.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/66617836.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/20134273.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/50601795.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/09028161.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/79573221.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/99781936.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/39640010.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/97659150.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/81941082.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/08093755.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/98812600.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/10284419.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/77258675.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/73852703.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/19010551.sHtML
http://m.star.langquan.net/Article/details/40839853.sHtML
热门跟贴